Independent

Super hard to dip brush in bottle to use, poor design. It's super thick and does not spread well.

I was going to buy eyeliner from another store after going to Lush and to my surprise they actually had their own eyeliner! I bought this on a whim without knowing anything about it and not reading any reviews, mainly because I like its sustainable packaging (glass jar). For the amount I paid, I felt like there was a generous amount in the jar that would last me a couple months (if not year) and it's still cheaper than most namebrand eyeliners from makeup stores. The application goes on matte, and it takes about 2-3 strokes to get a solid line, but after that it stays on well. I would say it's long-lasting seeing that I wore it on a work day and it lasted well into the night. From my experience, I would say it's water resistant but not quite water proof but that's good enough for me. I don't plan on swimming in it. Overall, a solid makeup product for those who are looking to switching to more sustainable makeup.

This eye liner goes on smoothly and it so dark and beautiful . it has become my go to eyeliner only thing is it comes off to easy .. if I add my lashes without even sticking just to get idea of how it looks the eyeliner come off where ever that lash touches

I really like this eyeliner and happy with the results. Stays on all day and applies easily. Looking forward to purchasing again and hopefully different colors in the future!

I love this product, purchased with the Get In There brush. It's a bit tricky to use at first but after a couple tries it's a breeze and a perfect winged tip. The eyeliner stays on alllll day, I can sleep in it and wake up with perfect eyeliner!!! It doesn't flake off at all, but it still washes off with just water in one swipe. The glass jar can be recycled making this a very eco friendly product (which is way I purchased it initially). And of course the fact that it's also cruelty free makes this a must! Will definitely keep purchasing!!!!

This is by far my favorite Lush product. It is amazing and everyone should buy it so they never retire it again and leave me to order it from the UK and pay a currency conversion fee and hefty shipping. Why is this eyeliner so awesome? Well, I find that liquid eyeliner mostly comes in three forms. There is a very wet sort, kind of like watercolor paint. This sort takes several applications (which I find difficult to make look tidy) to achieve a rich color effect. The other two kinds are more like a thick paint, but one is waterproof. I've found that if liquid eyeliner isn't waterproof, it doesn't last and it does smudge. The wrong waterproof eyeliner can flake off like dried paint and get embedded in your eyelids (been there, done that $200 opthalmologist bill). Anyway, Independent has the best aspects of all liquid eyeliners without the failings. One swipe gets a dark color effect, it doesn't flake off, doesn't smudge and it stays put until you decide to wash it off. I was in labor for three days with my first baby and the only thing that looked good at the end was the baby and my eyeliner. Facts. I think it might not have taken well when it was originally launched because the brush it came with was pretty terrible. I have been using a $2 cheapo brush I got at Target and it has been a huge improvement. I suspect the brush from Lush is even better and I plan on trying it on my next stock up. Long story short, I just adore this product and I hope others give it a chance so we can all have it Stateside for the foreseeable future.

This eyeliner is easy to use, and it stays on ALL. DAY. LONG. Literally the only downside is the package; the bottle is tall and and thin so it's a little hard to judge if you actually dipped the tip of your brush in or if you completely covered it lol.

I don't love the product, sad to say. I had high hopes, but it rubs off when applying.

I hope this will never be discontinued. Tried several more expensive bramds (waterproof)but this is the only one that worked for my very oily skin. It stays on like forever. Doesnt bleed, doesnt flake.